This healthier peanut butter pie is made better for you with natural peanut butter, just a little honey and a grain-free chocolate crust! For a more traditional crust, use this chocolate cookie pie crust.
I’m super excited to be sharing this with you today! Like, ridiculously, almost-peeing-in-my-pants excited. Peanut butter pie has always been my favorite pie but I didn’t think it could be made healthier and still actually be tasty. I’m not a fan of natural peanut butter in baked goods and for some reason, I didn’t think it’d be good in pie but I was very happy to be proven wrong! I also had major doubts about naturally sweetening a peanut butter pie but only three tablespoons of honey was enough to nicely sweeten the entire filling. And there wasn’t any honey aftertaste!
The crust is also naturally sweetened with dates and honey. There are three tablespoons of chocolate chips in the dough but we needn’t even think about them. If you really want to, you can omit them.
Instead of regular whipped cream, I used whipped coconut cream. You refrigerate a can of coconut milk overnight, scoop out the cream that forms on top, and whip it. That’s all it is! Super easy but requires a little planning. You can also use regular whipped cream if you prefer.
This is the perfect dessert for when you need some peanut butter and chocolate goodness but don’t want to turn on the oven! You normally have to bake the crust of a peanut butter pie, but this one is totally no-bake and raw. The grain-free crust is adapted from my chocolate hazelnut fudge bites. I subbed almonds for the hazelnuts but you could definitely use peanuts if you prefer! I just went almonds because they’re supposed to be more healthy than peanuts.
The crust isn’t crisp like a regular crust, and with a day in the refrigerator, it’s quite soft. If that bothers you, spread a layer of ganache over the crust. I’d make about half of this recipe. I’m kicking myself that I didn’t do that myself! If you have any leftover, you can always drizzle it on top.
And yes, this is technically a tart. I don’t have any non-fluted pie pans and this no-bake crust just wouldn’t have done well in one of those. If you want to use a regular pie pan and have a little too much crust, just roll the dough into balls and refrigerate! That is, after all, how that dough was intended to be eaten.
I used cream cheese in this because peanut butter pie just isn’t peanut butter pie without cream cheese. So sorry to my vegan and dairy-free friends! Though I suppose this homemade vegan and paleo cream cheese work work just fine. I’m not promising anything, though. Make sure to use agave instead of honey for a vegan version of the pie filling. For a peanut free version of this pie, replace the peanut butter in the topping with almond butter!
The only annoying thing is that this recipe doesn’t use the entire can of coconut milk. It just uses the cream part, and not even all of it (though it would if you want to use cream as a garnish!) I didn’t add as much whipped cream as a regular peanut butter pie because I didn’t want to taste the coconut at all. A coconut peanut butter pie sounds amazing, but that’s not what I was going for here.
With the store brand coconut cream I used, I didn’t detect the slightest bit of coconut flavor and I’m hoping that this will be true for all brands. But I still wouldn’t bother making this pie if you hate coconut just because there’s a chance your pie could taste a little coconut-y. As for the leftover coconut milk, I used it in this raspberry coconut smoothie.
Every brand of coconut milk I’ve tried has separated without problem, but I’ve read that some people have issues with certain brands. I haven’t tried it myself, but the Whole Foods brand of coconut milk is highly recommended. Thai Kitchen is, too, if you don’t mind BPA. See this post for brand comparisons and for step-by-step photos on how to whip coconut cream!
For the chocolate curls, I just used a block of milk chocolate and a potato peeler. Super simple! Though it took quite a while – about 10 minutes. Here’s a video that shows you how to make them.
This pie needs to be refrigerated or frozen and not left at room temperature for more than 15 minutes or so. It starts to soften quite quickly because of the runny natural peanut butter and honey. So this is not what you want to bring to a picnic! Unless you have a cooler. Then you can impress all your friends with your fancy healthier peanut butter pie.